Endure Weekly
Trail Shoe Decision Tree Buying Guide

How to pick trail running shoes.

Five questions, then a recommendation. Most trail-shoe guides drown you in 30 options; this one helps you eliminate 27 of them in under three minutes. Specific shoe picks for each profile.

№ 01

Decision 1 of 5

How technical is your terrain?

  • If — Smooth dirt / fire roads

    → Low-lug shoe (3–4mm). Hoka Mach X Trail, Saucony Endorphin Edge.

  • If — Rolling singletrack with some rocks

    → Medium-lug shoe (4–5mm). Hoka Speedgoat 6, Saucony Peregrine 14, Brooks Cascadia 18.

  • If — Technical mountain / rocks / roots

    → Aggressive lug (5–6mm) with rock plate. Salomon S/Lab Genesis, La Sportiva Mutant, Hoka Mafate Speed 4.

  • If — Wet roots / muddy / slick

    → Aggressive lug + grippy outsole compound. Inov-8 X-Talon, La Sportiva Cyklon Cross.

№ 02

Decision 2 of 5

How long is your typical run?

  • If — < 1 hour

    → Low cushion is fine. Saucony Peregrine, Salomon S/Lab Pulsar, Brooks Catamount.

  • If — 1–3 hours

    → Medium-cushion daily trainer. Hoka Speedgoat 6, Brooks Cascadia 18, Saucony Xodus Ultra 4.

  • If — 3+ hours / ultra training

    → Max-cushion shoe. Hoka Speedgoat 6, Hoka Mafate Speed 4, Tecnica Magma 2.0.

  • If — Race day, 100-miler

    → Max-cushion + carbon plate option. Hoka Tecton X 3, Speedland SG, Saucony Endorphin Edge.

№ 03

Decision 3 of 5

What's your foot shape?

  • If — Wide forefoot

    → Wide-toe-box brand. Altra (zero-drop), Topo Athletic, Hoka Speedgoat Wide.

  • If — Narrow heel, regular forefoot

    → Salomon, La Sportiva. The euro-cut brands have better heel hold.

  • If — Average (most runners)

    → Almost any brand. Hoka, Brooks, Saucony, Nike Trail are all reasonable starting points.

  • If — Bunions / sensitive forefoot

    → Wide-toe-box, low-drop. Altra Lone Peak, Topo Pursuit, Hoka Speedgoat Wide.

№ 04

Decision 4 of 5

How much heel-toe drop do you want?

  • If — Zero drop (advanced)

    → Altra (only major zero-drop brand). Lone Peak 9, Olympus 6. Requires strong calves and Achilles.

  • If — Low drop (4–5mm)

    → Hoka Speedgoat (5mm), Topo Pursuit (5mm), Saucony Peregrine (4mm). Forgiving on calves; good middle ground.

  • If — Medium drop (6–8mm)

    → Brooks Cascadia (8mm), Salomon Genesis (8mm). The default for road-runners moving to trail.

  • If — High drop (10–12mm)

    → Most cushioned trail shoes. Hoka Mafate (8mm but feels higher), Saucony Xodus, Nike Pegasus Trail.

№ 05

Decision 5 of 5

What's your race ahead?

  • If — No race / general fitness

    → Get a versatile daily-trainer. Hoka Speedgoat 6, Brooks Cascadia 18.

  • If — Mountain ultra (Hardrock, UTMB)

    → Aggressive-lug + max-cushion. Hoka Mafate Speed 4, Salomon Genesis, Tecnica Magma 2.0.

  • If — Runnable ultra (Western States, Vermont 100)

    → Max-cushion + carbon plate option. Hoka Speedgoat 6 or Tecton X 3.

  • If — Desert ultra (Cocodona, Black Canyon)

    → Half-size up. Mesh upper for breathability. Hoka Speedgoat 6, Topo Pursuit, Saucony Xodus.

Detailed reviews

When you're ready to buy.

Once you've narrowed by category, our researched reviews go deep on each specific shoe: fit, durability and who it is actually for, drawn from published specifications and the consensus of owner reports rather than from testing we have not done.

The fit rules

Five fit rules most runners ignore.

The right shoe in the wrong size is still wrong. Fit is more important than model selection.

  1. i.

    Half-size up for ultras

    Feet swell during long runs. Race day at mile 60 should feel slightly roomy, not perfectly fitted. The shoe that fits perfectly at the store is too tight at mile 60.

  2. ii.

    Try shoes in the afternoon

    Feet are larger by 4–8% in the afternoon. Morning shoe fittings produce shoes that hurt by mile 40 of a Saturday long run.

  3. iii.

    Rotate between two pairs

    Shoes need 24–48 hours to fully rebound between runs. Two-pair rotation extends total mileage by 30–50% and reduces overuse injury.

  4. iv.

    Replace at 350–500 miles

    Compressed midsole foam doesn't cushion. Track mileage in your watch. Most knee/calf injuries late in a training cycle are dead-shoe injuries.

  5. v.

    Don't race in new shoes

    Race-day shoes need 100+ training miles minimum. New shoes have surprises — hot spots, lacing pressure, heel-cup discomfort — that you don't want to discover at mile 70.

Endure Weekly · Free

Get the gear-and-training newsletter.

Wednesday letter from the studio. Plus the Ultimate Zone 2 Training Guide and the Race Day Checklist on signup.

Wednesday mornings. Free Zone 2 Training Guide on signup. Unsubscribe anytime.

What these sessions assume you are measuring with

Every pace, zone and power figure here needs something recording it. These three cover running, long days and the bike.

Garmin Forerunner 965 Garmin Forerunner 965

AMOLED multisport with the training-load and threshold metrics most of these sessions assume you can see day to day.

Check price on Amazon →
COROS APEX 2 Series GPS Watch COROS APEX 2 Series GPS Watch

Sapphire titanium and the longest battery in its class, which is the deciding feature once a day out runs past a few hours.

Check price on Amazon →
Favero Assioma Uno Power Meter Pedal Favero Assioma Uno Power Meter Pedal

Single-sided pedal power, the cheapest honest entry into training with watts rather than estimating from heart rate.

Check price on Amazon →

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.